Appeals Court uhpolds death sentence, long prison terms in Sidi Gaber case
Still from video of Sidi Gaber incident, 2013

The Appeals Court upheld a death sentence and long-term prison time for 58 people in a Thursday ruling, though some activists say not all the defendants were implicated in the heinous crimes that elicited the harsh verdict.

The defendants were convicted of murder, attempted murder, rioting and inciting violence during clashes between military supporters and Muslim Brotherhood protesters in Alexandria following former President Mohamed Morsi’s ouster in July 2013.

Mahmoud Hassan Ramadan was sentenced to death for throwing three young men from the rooftop of a high-rise building in Alexandria’s Sidi Gaber neighborhood. A 19-year-old man was killed in the incident, while the two other teens were critically injured. Video footage showed Ramadan and others throwing the victims from a water tank above the building onto the rooftop, and then later throwing them into the street. The video went viral shortly thereafter, provoking international outcry.

In March 2014, the Alexandria Criminal Court sentenced both Ramadan and co-defendant Mohamed al-Ahmady to death. On appeal, Ahmady’s sentenced was reduced to life in prison, along with 17 others who were also sentenced to life. In addition, eight defendants were sentenced to 15 years, 35 were sentenced to 10 years, and one defendant who was tried as a minor was sentenced to seven years.

Ayman Mahmoud, a lawyer representing the victims’ families, told Mada Masr that the clashes erupted when Brotherhood protesters were en route to demonstrate at the Northern Military District close to Sisi Gaber. Area residents then attacked the protest to prevent the Brotherhood supporters from torching the military facility.

The victims had climbed to the top of the building to throw rocks at Brotherhood protesters below, Mahmoud said.

“Brotherhood supporters went to the rooftop, stabbed some of the victims and threw them from the meters-high water tank stationed in the middle of the rooftop, then from the rooftop to the bottom of the building,” the lawyer recounted.

After his arrest, Ramadan — the defendant who appeared in the video of the incident with a long beard and brandishing an Al-Qaeda flag — publicly confessed to perpetrating the attack.

“I was astonished. What did we do?” he said during a recorded confession published at the time.

He accused the victims of harassing him and the rest of the demonstrators. “This made us even angrier,” he said.

Mohamed Gaber, an Alexandria-based activist and an eyewitness to the killings, told Mada Masr that he saw a group of bearded men grabbing two young men inside the building and beating them.

“They said, ‘We already killed another two,’ in a very celebratory tone,” he recounted.

But Gaber believes this is a particularly complicated case. Although many of those convicted did commit a brutal crime, other defendants were randomly arrested — some were even part of the pro-military side of the conflict, he says.

“There are killers, and there are some innocent people who were really randomly arrested. The case is in some ways different from the other mass death sentences handed down to Brotherhood supporters, but in some ways similar,” Gaber explained.

The Egyptian judiciary has been condemned for handing down mass death and jail sentences against Brotherhood supporters, and recently against non-Brotherhood activists as well. On Monday, the Giza Criminal Court sentenced 183 people to death on charges stemming from violence that broke out in the Giza town of Kerdasa in August 2013.

On Wednesday, activist Ahmed Douma and 229 others were sentenced to life in the “Cabinet clashes” case. They were also collectively fined LE17 million for damages to the Institut d’Egypte collection incurred during violent confrontations between protesters and military forces in December 2011.


You have a right to access accurate information, be stimulated by innovative and nuanced reporting, and be moved by compelling storytelling.

Subscribe now to become part of the growing community of members who help us maintain our editorial independence.
Know more

Join us

Your support is the only way to ensure independent,
progressive journalism