Translated by: 

Whether Mohamed Hassanein Heikal is preparing Field Marshal Abdel Fattah al-Sisi’s electoral program, as published by privately owned daily newspaper Youm7, or whether he is maintaining his position as an expert who never withholds advice as he has previously mentioned, there is one question that preoccupies me in both cases. Did Heikal recount to Sisi the details of his conversation with renowned British military commander Bernard Montgomery when the latter visited Egypt on the occasion of the 25th anniversary of the famous Alamein Battle? Back then, Heikal met with Montgomery and they had a long conversation.

Montgomery, who had the title of field marshal, expressed his astonishment at the granting of Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces Abdel Hakeem Amer the same title on a political basis, without any military achievements that would entitle him to the promotion. This astonishment was recounted by Heikal, who quoted Montgomery’s own words.

Heikal recounted the incident in his engaging book, “Revisiting History.” On page 180 of the Shorouk Publishing House edition, he wrote that Montgomery described Marshal Abdel Hakeem Amer as a political figure. “There is absolutely no need for a political marshal. Marshals claim their titles for leading troops in the field, and not because of anything else,” Montgomery said, according to Heikal. And this is how Heikal responded:

“I am not trying to convince you. How can I convince you of something I am not convinced of? I was explaining to you the situation. I wasn’t trying to set a norm. In fact, I am not a proponent of military intervention in politics,” Heikal told Montgomery.

“I interrupted him saying: ‘I may differ with you, however, why don’t you ask him when you meet him?’ So he said: ‘Can I really ask him that question when I meet him and would the question anger him?’ I said laughing, ‘I don’t know.”’

Mr. Heikal didn’t recount afterwards whether Montgomery asked this contentious question or not.

In his conversation with Heikal, Montgomery did not only raise the issue of granting Marshal Amer a military title without the necessary military accomplishments, he went straight to the heart of what he saw as a problem in Egypt, namely the relationship between military men and civilians.

He started his conversation by recounting a disagreement he once had with British Prime Minister Winston Churchill — one of the most important British politicians of all times — during World War II. Montgomery told Heikal that Churchill had sent him an angry message during the outbreak of a battle with the German army under the command of Marshal Erwin Romel, asking him to mount an offensive and not be confined to defensive tactics. Montgomery answered him back with a message that he dictated to his chief of staff, General Francis de Guingand, and it read: “I urge the prime minister to attend to his position and to leave me to my area of expertise.”

Montgomery asked his deputy General Guingand, who was accompanying him in Egypt and was at the meeting with Heikal, to testify to his account. Montgomery added, “I don’t like it when politicians turn into generals and I also don’t like it when generals turn into politicians.”

Heikal recounts his reaction as follows: “Suddenly, as I gave him all my attention, Montgomery crossed all barriers and asked me: ‘Why do generals in your country turn into politicians?’ I tried to stall for time by asking him, ‘which generals?’ He said quickly — ‘Nasser and his colleagues.’ I said, ‘Nasser is not a general and his last military title was colonel.’ He continued his attack and said, ‘Ok, let me amend the question — ‘Why do colonels turn into politicians?’ I said, ‘Ok, let me tell you the story in detail.’ I went on to explain to him the situation in Egypt, its development, the conditions surrounding the [1952] revolution, how those who orchestrated it were a group of young men from the army who undertook this action in their capacity as patriotic youth and not army officers. Their main mission was to usurp military command, so that the king would not use the Armed Forces against the people. The Armed Forces were under the service of the popular revolution, in order to safeguard its objectives. Then I explained the circumstances of the Third World in general, and the role played by the army here, which is the only institution capable of sustaining itself during times of crisis.”

Montgomery didn’t find Heikal’s explanation convincing, so he told him: “You didn’t manage to convince me.” And this was Heikal’s surprising response as he wrote it:

“I am not trying to convince you. How can I convince you of something I am not convinced of? I was explaining to you the situation. I wasn’t trying to set a norm. In fact, I am not a proponent of military intervention in politics. I don’t want generals to become politicians as much as you don’t want politicians to become generals. But, we are facing a phenomenon in Egypt and the whole Third World that requires an explanation. When I explain, I don’t use that as an excuse. I said: ‘At any rate, you will meet President Nasser and I suggest you ask him the same question yourself.’

Montgomery said: ‘You don’t think the question will anger him.’ I said: ‘I don’t think so.”’

Unfortunately, Mr. Heikal ended the chapter on his conversation with Montgomery without telling us whether he asked Nasser the question or not. And if so, what Nasser’s reaction was.

I wonder whether Mr. Heikal would answer our critical questions today, such as: “Is he still not a proponent of military intervention in politics and does he remain convinced that granting military titles for political reasons is a mistake? And, if he had viewed the intervention of Nasser and his military colleagues in 1952 as justified to prevent the king from clashing with the people, what is the excuse now for the military commander to move from the position as protector of the people to that of ruler?

The people have generally been fully appreciative of the Armed Forces thus far, but the military’s intervention in politics could deepen political rifts in society, freezing democratic development and returning Egypt back to repressive times; a move that is supported by state media, its resources and its intellectuals.

Until Mr. Heikal responds to these questions himself, if he wants to, I am left to conclude that Montgomery's fears have come true and that the officers’ intervention in politics has left Egypt defeated. I don’t need to remind you of the “naksa,” which took place only one month after Montgomery's visit, which was in May 1967. Only the policies of Colonel Gamal Abdel Nasser and Marshal Abdel Hakeem Amer are to be blamed.

May God protect Egypt.

This article was banned from publishing in privately owned daily newspaper Al-Shorouk.

This article has been translated from Arabic. You can read the original article here.

Comments

I don't get why this article

I don't get why this article was deemed controversial. It says nothing

Great items from you, man. I

Great items from you, man. I have remember your
stuff prior to and you are simply extremely great.
I really like what you've bought right here, certainly like what you're saying
and the way in which wherein you are saying it. You are making it
enjoyable and you continue to take care of to stay it smart.
I cant wait to learn much more from you. This is really a
wonderful website.

Otherwise, hair may recede

Otherwise, hair may recede and erode further beyond your transplant,
requiring additional surgeries in the future, because male pattern baldness is a
progressive condition of hair loss over time. Neither scenarios are conducive to the length of time (at least 30 days) most blacks wear cornrows, micro braids or single braids.
Hair loss will not only have an adverse effect on your looks and personality but also predisposes you
to early age baldness creating a trouble for you.

I was at first shocked and

I was at first shocked and then giddy with excitement as I went
and started catching hoppers. They just launch in to the next part of their game.
Boating Suite is a professional, full-featured app for the i
- Phone, i - Pad or i - Pod Touch that is
designed to help boaters manage all aspects of their boating activities.

Bear in mind that it usually

Bear in mind that it usually takes six months after giving birth for your body to return to normal.
There is an outline of the food guide one is to follow
during this period. If you cannot resist eating something more than expected, it is at all times recommended sticking to your HCG
diet and weight loss program as much as possible.

In addition, you be

In addition, you be interested in that the weight
loss doesnt have get complication over your body. Products
that contain other yeasts can also be included in the diet as they will help
to contain candida yeast. The use of beauty products is
one of the everyday regimens of women.

To know more about the types

To know more about the types of cosmetic surgery procedures and how it changed people's lives, check out Dr.
Wondering how to get a boob job is more than just the surgery,
it is the recovery and the lifetime of having the
implants in your body and issues that may occur years later.
Complications while on surgery or after operation side-effects can occur.

The internet is a great

The internet is a great marketing tool because it is cheap and efficient.

There are many SEO companies who have started early, and in order to capitalize the market
they offer their service at affordable rate.
Sales still need to happen, but sales happen because
of a successful relationship.

Because your balance sheet is

Because your balance sheet is a snapshot of your business
at any given time, it needs the totals from your general ledger sub-accounts.

Total salary is reported to the employees and Internal revenue service which become easy
for the employees to pay their taxes. You would expect me to say that, but it is true that the best
way to ensure the minimum of difficulties with HMRC is to use a professional.

Many people advertise

Many people advertise affiliate marketing as something that can be
started for fairly cheap. You should always keep yourself abreast with
the latest happenings in the seo world. This involves
figuring out where your target customers are networking online and making certain that your organization has a presence in the social media outlets
that they are participating in.

However there are some

However there are some exemptions for which the landowner will not be held accountable,
such as: any kind of flue which is connected to the gas appliance which is owned
personally by the landowner or by the tenant.

An important commercial, banking and industrial area,
Lyon is an extremely attractive city. From what I'd so dissentingly
encountered over the years, in the case of various "ministers,"
to the point where I'm not even welcome to attend; it appears they aspire to being, not "mere" guides, but
more like the most self-indulgent, Papally Infallible "Gurus" (I Peter 5:3).

I don't get why this article

I don't get why this article was deemed controversial. It says nothing

Used tanning beds offer the

Used tanning beds offer the perfect solution to getting a great tan at
a really affordable price. Similarly, the resin found in high quality resin wicker
pool furniture is just as rugged and weather resistant.
Beauty - Look at this outstanding blog post by simply clicking this wonderful website -.

Hello, Neat post. There is an

Hello, Neat post. There is an issue with your website in internet explorer, could
test this? IE still is the market chief and a huge portion of
folks will omit your great writing due to this problem.

I've been surfing online more

I've been surfing online more than 4 hours today, yet I never
found any interesting article like yours. It's pretty worth
enough for me. In my view, if all site owners and
bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

I blog quite often and I

I blog quite often and I truly thank you for your content.
The article has truly peaked my interest. I will book mark your site and keep checking for new
information about once a week. I opted in for your Feed too.

Oh my goodness! Awesome

Oh my goodness! Awesome article dude! Many thanks, However I am having difficulties
with your RSS. I don't know the reason why I am unable to
join it. Is there anybody having similar RSS problems?

Anyone who knows the solution will you kindly respond?
Thanks!!

I've been surfing on-line

I've been surfing on-line more than 3 hours nowadays, yet I never found any interesting article like yours.
It's pretty worth sufficient for me. In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made just right content material as you probably did, the web will probably be much
more helpful than ever before.

You should take the time to

You should take the time to evaluate what it is that you simply're most seeking to gain from your buy, after which have a look at those companies that seem to best understand
not only what you are trying to accomplish, but in addition how finest
to do it. In case you take the best approach to Buying
Fb likes, and choose the correct company, it'll go a great distance towards maximizing
your advertising funds. I surveyed a pair dozen Facebook buddies.

Add new comment